← ALL FILESPOLICY COMPARISONPROPOSED

WARNING FILE · MECHANISM BEFORE MARKETING

Publicly owned renewable energy

Public entities own or operate energy assets rather than relying exclusively on private ownership.

01 / CURRENT RECORD

Public entities own or operate energy assets rather than relying exclusively on private ownership.

NEW YORK ASSEMBLY BIO
02 / MATERIAL LINK TEST

Ownership is a direct comparison axis; sector, compensation, competition, and governance define its scope.

READ THE STANDARD →
03

MARXIST / SOCIALIST / COMMUNIST PRECEDENTS

DIRECT MATERIAL LINK

MARXIST / COMMUNIST

Karl Marx & Friedrich Engels · 1848

HISTORICAL MECHANISMThe Communist Manifesto calls for abolition of bourgeois private property and conversion of capital into common property.

WHAT MATCHESDirect ideological link where a modern proposal transfers productive assets from private to collective or state ownership.

WHAT DIFFERSA tax-funded service or isolated regulation is not, by itself, abolition of private ownership.

COMMUNIST MANIFESTO · CHAPTER II
DIRECT MATERIAL LINK

SOVIET COMMUNIST

Union of Soviet Socialist Republics · 1936 Constitution · Articles 4–7

HISTORICAL MECHANISMThe Soviet constitutional order made state and collective ownership the economic foundation and placed major industry, transport, banks, land, and much urban housing in state ownership.

WHAT MATCHESDirect ownership link when a proposal replaces private ownership of an asset class with government or collective ownership.

WHAT DIFFERSThe Soviet system abolished private ownership of productive assets across the economy; a sector-limited public option is narrower.

LIBRARY OF CONGRESS · 1936 USSR CONSTITUTION
04

CONSTITUTION & BILL OF RIGHTS

FACT-SPECIFIC CONSTITUTIONAL TEST

PRIVATE PROPERTY & DUE PROCESS

Fifth Amendment

Test whether government compels transfer, occupation, confiscation, or deprivation of property and whether compensation and due process are provided.

NATIONAL ARCHIVES · BILL OF RIGHTS
05

DEATH RECORDS CONNECTED TO THIS MECHANISM

Poster-style historical portrait of Joseph Stalin
20M DEAD
01MARXIST-LENINIST / COMMUNIST

STALIN'S SOVIET UNION · 1924–1953

Joseph Stalin

ESTIMATED 20 MILLION DEAD

WHAT THE REGIME DIDCollectivization, famine, executions, terror, and forced labor

ECONOMIC CONSEQUENCEForced collectivization destroyed private agricultural control, seized grain, deported farming families, and contributed to catastrophic famine while the command economy redirected labor and capital by state order.

WHAT THE NUMBER COVERSHistorian Roy Medvedev's widely cited estimate attributes about 20 million deaths to labor camps, forced collectivization, famine, and executions during Stalin's rule. Other scholarly estimates differ, so the figure is labeled as an estimate.

Poster-style historical portrait of Mao Zedong
23–30M DEAD
02MARXIST-LENINIST / MAOIST COMMUNIST

MAO'S PEOPLE'S REPUBLIC OF CHINA · 1959–1961

Mao Zedong

23–30 MILLION EXCESS DEATHS

WHAT THE REGIME DIDGreat Leap Forward and the resulting national famine

ECONOMIC CONSEQUENCECompulsory collectivization, unrealistic production targets, grain procurement, and falsified reports disrupted agriculture and concealed starvation on a national scale.

WHAT THE NUMBER COVERSDemographic reconstructions vary. The reviewed medical history traces the largely manmade catastrophe to Mao's Great Leap Forward decision and Chinese Communist Party implementation.

Poster-style historical portrait of Adolf Hitler in uniform
60–80M WWII
03NATIONAL SOCIALIST / FASCIST / RACIAL-NATIONALIST

NAZI GERMANY · 1933–1945

Adolf Hitler

ESTIMATED 60–80 MILLION WWII DEAD WORLDWIDE

WHAT THE REGIME DIDAggressive war in Europe, the Holocaust, and state-organized racial, political, and ideological mass murder

ECONOMIC CONSEQUENCEThe dictatorship confiscated property, destroyed independent unions and civil institutions, directed labor and industry toward rearmament and war, and left Germany and much of Europe devastated.

WHAT THE NUMBER COVERSHitler's invasion of Poland began World War II in Europe. Estimates of total worldwide wartime deaths vary widely; this global range includes every theater, belligerent, genocide, famine, and war-related cause, so it is not a count of people personally killed by Hitler or Nazi Germany alone. Within that total, the Nazi regime and its allies murdered six million Jewish people and millions of other victims.

Historical portrait of Vladimir Lenin in poster treatment
50K–200K DEAD
04MARXIST-LENINIST / COMMUNIST

BOLSHEVIK RUSSIA · 1918–1922

Vladimir Lenin

ESTIMATED 50,000–200,000 RED TERROR DEATHS

WHAT THE REGIME DIDRed Terror executions, political repression, grain requisition, and coercive War Communism

ECONOMIC CONSEQUENCEWar Communism nationalized production, requisitioned grain, restricted private trade, and intensified economic collapse before Lenin retreated to the New Economic Policy.

WHAT THE NUMBER COVERSSurviving records are incomplete and scholarly estimates vary widely. The displayed range concerns Red Terror killings, not every Civil War or famine death during Lenin's government.

Historical portrait of Pol Pot in poster treatment
~2M DEAD
05MAOIST / COMMUNIST

KHMER ROUGE CAMBODIA · 1975–1979

Pol Pot

NEARLY 2 MILLION DEAD

WHAT THE REGIME DIDForced labor, thought control, mass execution, starvation, and destruction of urban society

ECONOMIC CONSEQUENCEThe regime emptied cities, abolished ordinary markets and money, collectivized labor and food, and attempted to construct an agrarian classless state through coercion.

WHAT THE NUMBER COVERSThe U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum attributes nearly two million deaths to Khmer Rouge rule and its program of forced labor, thought control, starvation, and execution.

Historical portrait of Fidel Castro in poster treatment
HUNDREDS DEAD
06MARXIST-LENINIST / COMMUNIST

REVOLUTIONARY CUBA · 1959–2008

Fidel Castro

HUNDREDS OF SUMMARY EXECUTIONS DOCUMENTED

WHAT THE REGIME DIDSummary executions after revolutionary trials, political imprisonment, and systematic repression of dissent

ECONOMIC CONSEQUENCENationalization, central planning, restrictions on private enterprise, and political control over employment and information produced a state-dominated economy with chronic shortages and limited individual economic choice.

WHAT THE NUMBER COVERSAmnesty International documents hundreds of summary executions following Castro's 1959 takeover while noting the absence of a reliable consolidated total for all deaths attributable to the regime.

Historical portrait of North Korean founder Kim Il Sung in poster treatment
600K–1M DEAD
07JUCHE / COMMUNIST ONE-PARTY STATE

NORTH KOREA · 1948–PRESENT; FAMINE PEAK 1990s

Kim Il Sung / Kim Jong Il / Kim Jong Un

600,000–1 MILLION FAMINE DEATHS

WHAT THE REGIME DIDPolitical prison camps, state food allocation, repression, and policy-driven starvation

ECONOMIC CONSEQUENCECentral allocation, restrictions on trade and movement, political distribution of food, and military-first priorities deepened scarcity and prevented ordinary market responses.

WHAT THE NUMBER COVERSResearch estimates 600,000 to one million famine deaths. A UN commission found that state decisions violating the right to food were adopted with awareness that they would worsen starvation and related deaths.

Historical portrait of Mengistu Haile Mariam in poster treatment
500K+ DEAD
08MARXIST-LENINIST MILITARY REGIME

ETHIOPIA'S DERG · 1974–1991

Mengistu Haile Mariam

AT LEAST 500,000 CIVILIANS DEAD

WHAT THE REGIME DIDRed Terror, counterinsurgency, forced relocation, attacks on civilians, and use of food as a weapon

ECONOMIC CONSEQUENCENationalization, collectivization, forced resettlement, prolonged war, and manipulation of relief supplies destroyed livelihoods and aggravated famine.

WHAT THE NUMBER COVERSHuman Rights Watch attributes at least half a million civilian deaths to Derg actions, including indiscriminate violence, forced relocation, counterinsurgency, and policies that helped create famine.

Poster-style historical portrait of Saddam Hussein
100K+ DEAD
10AUTHORITARIAN ARAB NATIONALIST / BA'ATHIST SOCIALIST

BA'ATHIST IRAQ · 1979–2003; ANFAL 1987–1988

Saddam Hussein

MORE THAN 100,000 KURDS KILLED IN ANFAL

WHAT THE REGIME DIDAnfal genocide, disappearances, chemical attacks, prison killings, and political terror

ECONOMIC CONSEQUENCECentralized oil power, militarization, patronage, war, sanctions, and destruction of civilian communities consumed national wealth and displaced hundreds of thousands.

WHAT THE NUMBER COVERSHuman Rights Watch states that more than 100,000 Iraqi Kurds were killed in the Anfal campaign and documents Saddam Hussein's personal supervisory role.

Historical portrait of Nicolae Ceaușescu in poster treatment
9,542 DEAD
11MARXIST-LENINIST / COMMUNIST

COMMUNIST ROMANIA · 1966–1989

Nicolae Ceaușescu

9,542 MATERNAL DEATHS REPORTED

WHAT THE REGIME DIDDecree 770: abortion and contraception restrictions enforced through intrusive state population policy

ECONOMIC CONSEQUENCEThe state used surveillance, workplace penalties, and medical controls to pursue population targets while austerity and central planning produced severe shortages.

WHAT THE NUMBER COVERSA peer-reviewed medical review reports 9,542 maternal deaths from illegal abortions or birth-related complications during the period of Ceaușescu's coercive pronatalist decree.

LINKED CURRENT FIGURES

Claire Valdez Democratic nominee · U.S. House NY-7